Types of Liberalism

Classical

Revolution

Negative liberty

  • JSM’s On Liberty
  • freedom = individuals left alone to determine their own destiny
  • harm principle: unless a man’s exercise of liberty ‘harmed’ that of others, any interference is an infringement on his right to freedom

Minimal government

  • governments should be limited not only how they act but whether they act
  • “the government which governs best is that which governs least” -Thoreau
  • Jefferson: “When government grows, our liberty withers.”

Laissez-faire capitalism

  • von Hiack: Road to Serfdom (1944)
    • a large state will limit freedom by tying an individual directly to the state

Ambivalent about democracy

  • Locke and Founding Fathers felt that universal adult suffrage (which empowers the majority) threatened the ‘natural’ property rights of a minority
    • hence right to vote should be limited to property owners
  • JSM argued that democracy complemented developmental individualism
    • engagement with politics and ‘rationally’ deciding who to support would increase ability to reason
      • supports votes for women
  • JSM fears a tyranny of majority
    • universal suffrage must be preceded by education
    • a judiciary to protect the natural rights of citizens from constitution and Bill of Rights
    • plural voting: educated elite should vote in Oxbridge + their own constituency
      • ensures a competent minority retains a voice in legislature

Developmental

Transitional

  • John Stuart Mill: classical thinker, with ideas moving towards modern
    • e.g. education

Modern

  • Thomas Hill Green: increased state intervention, “help those who cannot help themselves”
  • Betty Friedan, John Rawls
  • David Llyod George (PM 1916-1922), FDR, Keynes
  • In response to increased industrialisation causing greater reliance on industry for work, urban landlords for homes, etc
    • laissez-faire governments could only ensure liberty for the rural ‘atomised’ societies of Locke
  • TH Green: liberals now faced new enemies that were social and economic
    • Five Giants (Beveridge report)

Positive liberty

  • In contrast to Mill’s negative liberty
  • Freedom is not absence of restraint, it is empowering individuals to help themselves
  • Help those who cannot hepl themselves

Enabling state

Keynesian capitalism

  • Peroidic minimal state intervention

Neo-liberal