3.2.1.5 The electoral process and direct democracy

Electoral process

  • Fixed cycle system
  • Campaigns are very long
    • Often accused of being a distraction
  • FPTP system
  • Emphasis on individual candidates rather than party

Presidential elections

  • National Nominating Convention (NNC)
    • Held by each party to formally elect their presidential candidate
  • Indirect through Electoral College

Congressional elections

  • Directly elected
  • Every 2 years for the whole House and 1/3 of Senate

Primaries and caucuses

State, local, and primary elections

  • Timing decided by individual states
  • Once or twice a year
  • Election laws are state-based
    • e.g. Georgia has two rounds, i.e. top candidate needs >50% to win or there is a runoff between top two after 8 weeks
    • Maine uses STV-ish
    • California has a non-partisan “jungle primary” for the whole state, top two are in the Senate race
      • Usually both will be D, in June 2018 there was no R on the ballot

Direct democracy

  • Ballot initatives
  • Referendums
  • Recall elections
    • No constitutional provision for recalling members of Congress or SCOTUS justices
  • Mainly exists at state level only

Realigning elections

1932 New Deal Realignment

  • Great Depression resulted in a new Dem coalition united by shared preference for greater state intervention to address unemployment, poverty, economic instability
  • Dem Coalition
    • Working class
    • Low income
    • Trade unions + blue collar
    • Southern white farmers + labourers
    • Racial + religious minorities
  • R Coalition
    • Middle + upper class
    • Wealthier individuals + professionals
    • Business owners + corporate interests
    • Prosperous farmers
    • Northern, white protestants

Unity within parties

  • Balancing interests of core party and moderates
  • e.g. Culinary Workers Union, core member of Dems, opposed Sadner’s “Medicare for All” plan in 2020
  • Obama stopped short of creating single hantional health insurance that would have been opposed by union

Split-ticket voting and abstention

  • Generally low turnout despite lots of elections
    • Voter fatigue
  • Have to preregister to vote
    • In UK, required by law to register
    • Disporportionally affects those disadvantaged
  • Vastly differing voting methods between states
    • Postal voting
      • Colorado, Oregon, Washington have all-mail voting
      • Some states block postal voting and need a reason to do so
    • Voter ID
    • Onerous nomination criteria
    • Complicated ballot sheets
      • Accidentally spoil the ballot
  • Ideological reasons
    • Two party system, discriminates against third-party and indepdendent candidates – “wasted votes”
    • Lack of political change, voters feel that there is no change from their vote
    • Uncompetitive districts due to gerrymandering
  • People have to go to work on Tuesdays